Earlier today, we presented a trio of puzzles involving the digit 11. Here they are, revisited along with their explanations.
1. Funny Formation
You are the manager of a soccer team. The players wear shirt jersey numbers from 1 to 11, with the goalkeeper wearing number 1. The challenge is to divide the remaining outfield players into three groups: defenders, midfielders, and forwards.
The question is: Can you arrange the team so that the sum of the shirt numbers in every unit is evenly divided by 11?
Provide an example, or prove it cannot be done.
Answer
It is not possible.
The total sum of all numbers from 1 to 11 is 66. So, the combined total for the ten field players is 66 - 1 = 65.
Should the totals for the defenders, midfielders, and forwards were all multiples of 11, then their combined sum would also be divisible by 11. However, we see this is not true, because 65 cannot be divided evenly by 11.
2. Palindromic Products
When learning our multiplication tables, the 11-times table seems delightfully simple.
11 × 1 = 11
11 × 2 = 22
11 × 3 = 33
…
11 × 9 = 99
All these results are palindromes (numbers that are identical backwards and forwards).
If we continue up to 11 × 99, how many more answers are palindromes?
Solution
We find nine more.
Consider the method of multiplying by 11. When a two-digit number has digits a and b, the product with 11 is created by writing the first digit, then their sum, then the second digit—provided no regrouping is needed.
For example, 11 × 52 = 572, because the middle digit is simply 5 + 2 = 7.
i) Identical Digits (four solutions)
If the two digits are the same, as in 11, 22, 33, or 44, then the product with 11 yields 121, 242, 363, and 484—all palindromes.
This works only as long as the sum in the middle remains under 10, restricting us to these four cases.
ii) “Consecutive” Numbers (four cases)
Now consider numbers where the last digit is one larger than the first. Here, the outer digits of the product match, producing palindromes.
- 11 × 56 = 616
- 11 × 67 = 737
- 11 × 78 = 858
- 11 × 89 = 979
iii) The Last Example (single case)
At higher values, the product is a four-digit number. The first digit will be a 1, so the sole chance for a palindrome is when the last digit is also 1. Let's test 91 shows it succeeds! 11 × 91 = 1001.
3. Big Divide
Not as famous than other divisibility rules, there is a simple method to check for divisibility by 11.
Take the digits of a number and sum them in turn with plus and minus signs (starting with a plus). Should the total is a multiple of 11 (including 0), then the original number is a multiple of 11.
For instance, for 132 we calculate +1 - 3 + 2 = 0, so 132 is divisible by 11.
Using each of the digits 0–9 exactly once, construct the largest possible 10-digit number that is a multiple of 11.
Solution
The number is 9876524130.
The largest 10-digit number using the digits 0–9 once each is 9876543210.
Using the divisibility test for 11, we contrast the sum of digits in odd places with the sum in even places. For this number:
- Odd positions: 9, 7, 5, 3, 1 total 25.
- Digits in even places: 8, 6, 4, 2, 0 sum to 20.
Their difference is 5, which is not a multiple of 11.
Because the sum of all digits 0–9 is 45, the two sums must always add to 45, so their difference cannot be 0. The nearest multiple of 11 we can aim for is therefore 11.
To keep the number as large as possible, we try to preserve the largest starting digits. If the number began 987654…
The digits fixed so far contribute a difference of (9+7+5) - (8+6+4) = 3. The remaining digits 3,2,1,0 would need to contribute 8, but in the best arrangement they can only contribute (3+1) - (2+0) = 2. So no number starting 987654… will succeed.
Now try keeping the prefix 98765…
These digits contribute a difference of (9+7+5) - (8+6) = 7. The remaining digits 4,3,2,1,0 must contribute exactly 4.
To make as large as possible the difference, place the largest remaining digits, 4 and 3, into odd places, and 2,1,0 into even places. This yields (4+3) - (2+1+0) = 4, exactly what we need.
Arranged to maintain the number as great as possible, this gives us 9876524130.
Verifying confirms: the odd-position sum is 28, the even-position sum is 17, and 28 - 17 = 11, so the number is indeed divisible by 11.
We hope you enjoyed these challenges. Further problems will be coming in the future.